Discussion about this post

User's avatar
bobbert's avatar

Yeah, that's kind of my thought. The one thing you can't gerrymander is the whole state's population and representative count.

Expand full comment
JustPixelz: IV%'er's avatar

<i>"If James Madison had asked me, and I had been there, I would have said a popular vote is a better way to do it."</i>

The Founders were suspicious of popular vote and protective of state prerogatives. Senators were selected by some or most state legislatures until the 17th Amendment required direct election. TP'ers and some Repubicans <a href="http:\/\/www.rollcall.com\/news\/GOP-Senate-Candidates-Advocate-17th-Amendment-Repeal-216856-1.html" target="_blank">HATE</a> the 17th Amendment because .... well, I guess it's too democratic or maybe too Democratic.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?