Remember that movie they made you watch in 6th grade, the Eames Brothers’ “Powers of Ten”? It starts out one meter above a picnic in Chicago, then zooms out ten times, and out another ten times, and in three minutes or so, you’re at the edge of the galaxy?
Jon Ronson has written a story that pretty much does that with income inequality in America. He starts by interviewing a Haitian immigrant in Miami getting by on minimum wage, then interviews a nice Midwestern couple who make five times as much, and so on, going up the wage ladder by powers of five until he talks to a dickhole billionaire who suffers Wagnerian levels of butthurt because all the lazy people below him have decided that, as a mega-rich guy, he’s suddenly “an enemy of the state” for some reason he cannot fathom.
Ronson, author of the highly improbable but purportedly nonfictional The Men Who Stare At Goats, presents a lucid, thoughtful tour of the American income spectrum, six pointilist portraits of how some of us relate to money. At the near-bottom is Maurose Frantz, who works in the kitchen of a ritzy restaurant but has never even seen a customer. He dreams of making enough money to get the hell out of Florida. The nice folks in Ohio are worried about being able to pay for their insurance, but think Ronson, a Brit, just has to be lying when he says that not only is the National Health Service not collapsing, most British people are proud of how well it works.
And so on, up the scale; second from the top is a refreshingly class-traitor-y peach of a rich guy, Nick Hanauer, who got ridiculously rich by investing in this thing thought up by his pal Jeff Bezos called “Amazon.com.” Hanauer, who frequently bursts out laughing like some kind of demented eccentric out of Dickens, believes that “the system he benefits so richly from is built on nonsense”:
And the biggest nonsense of all, he says, “is the idea that because the rich are the smartest, and because we’re the job creators, the richer we get, the better it is for everyone. So taxes on the rich should be very, very low because we’re essentially the center of the economic universe, the font of productivity.” Nick pauses. “If there were a shred of truth to the claim that the rich are our nation’s job creators, then given how rich the rich have gotten, America should be drowning in jobs!”
Rich lucky guys like him don’t create jobs, he says: The middle class does. Told that the nice Ohio couple can’t afford to drive across the state for their anniversary, Hannauer exclaims, “It’s not fair, and it’s terrible for business. The best ideas in the world aren’t worth jack shit unless you have someone to sell to.”
Ronson ends with a portrait of loathsome fucktoad B. Wayne Hughes, who barely scrapes by on $625,000 a week and believes that anyone not as rich as he is just irresponsible and lazy. He believes that his success is all due to the secret of wealth (do good deeds anonymously) found in a 1939 potboiler, Dr. Hudson’s Secret Journal. Oh, crap, now we ALL know! But it’s entirely up to the individual to do good deeds — taxation will destroy the magic and create parasites like all those “derelicts on welfare” that he’s certain are filling America’s hospitals because they’re “bored” and “want feeding.”
While Ronson’s conclusions are perhaps less than earth-shattering (he notes that the billionaire “is the only one who seems angry about the politics of his situation”), they are illustrated with some telling details, and with narratives that might, just maybe, become part of the story that we’re telling about wealth disparities in this country.* At the very least, in six short pages, he illustrates the astronomical distance between the grotty little planet where most of us live, and the economic Oort cloud inhabited by those with the most wealth. (And really, they could stand to tighten their Kuiper Belt a little…)
Also, here is a graph showing American distribution of wealth through the use of cats and a pizza.
* For a nice think-piece about why people so often buy into systems that perpetuate inequality — the “what’s the matter with Kansas” question — check out this series by Crommunist, which may be, depending on your taste, deliciously brilliant or a big pile of tl;dr. We link, you decide.
[GQ]





{ 143 comments }
Today we are all the Joads.
The Eames weren't brothers; marrieds
"Maurose Frantz"? OK, sure.
That's pronounced "Morose France".
Mais tout les Francais sont heureux!
Peut tu le reprocher? Ils sont français!!
Rich people create jobs like hurricanes create levees.
"Wagnerian levels of butthurt" +1
But remember, it ain't class warfare unless it's being waged on the rich, according to GOP Baby Jeebus.
I earn extra cash and qualify for neato prizes by selling Burpee seeds and Grit Magazine door-to-door.
Enough to buy X-Ray Specs, Black Soap and a Charles Atlas Booklet!
You forgot onion gum.
Personally, I'm saving up for the "Build Your Own Hovercraft" kit.
Really? You can get that?
Because mine is full of eels…
No child in America should go Hungary
SEAHORSES!
40 years later, I am still pissed off about that packet of water-gnats!!
Brine shrimp are fun, if you have a fish.
Say, just how do poor white trash kids make money nowadays? I can't imagine mom cuts them in for a share of the meth profits.
Drug delivery, lookouts, numbers runners, prostitutes. An enterprising kid can always raise some scratch.
James O'Keefe is a role model?
Or maybe Wee-Bey
Nude spreads in Playgirl.
"how do poor white trash kids make money nowadays? I can't imagine mom cuts them in for a share of the meth profits"
No, she doesn't, so they're forced to impregnate the governor's slutty daughter.
I had a subscription to Grit when I was a little kid. I loved that magazine. Bought my Burpees at the hardware store, though.
Grit is now a Mother Earth News clone and available at magazine stands in the gardening/hobby farming section. So far as seeds go get this free catalog: http://rareseeds.com/requestcatalog/
It must have cost a fortune to produce so it'll keep printers in jobs and cost the site's owners money (they're vegans).
I'll wait for the Maxim version.
"Crowd In The Balcony — The Top-Heaviest Lady Oligarchs From The Bottom Up"
I spent five years in the UK returning to the States last August. The NHS was excellent with an emphasis on prevention that was refreshing. When my elderly MIL visited us and became ill she was treated at the Chelsea and Westminster A&E with no charge and great results.
I would gladly switch the system we currently have for that we enjoyed in the UK.
p.s.When I visted my GP I never had to wait more than 5 minutes. Amazing, simply amazing.
I lived in England off and on for six years. Even the people who weren't extatic about NHS could not imagine replacing it with what we have in the USA.
I had a….disagreement….with a conservative Canadian this weekend over the fact his friend had to live two years with pericarditis before he had minor surgery to drain the fluid, which I won by pointing out if he lived in the US, he wouldn't have made it to two years.
I had an argument today with somebody moaning about grown adults (26) staying on their parents' health care policies. I ended up in agreement — hey, they're starving anyway, why waste money on health care.
I've lived in Canada for over six years now and I cannot stress how much I love the Canadian health care system. I will tell anyone who asks, and most that don't, just that. It's not flawless certainly, but what is?
I hope beyond hope that Vermont will successfully pull off a single payer system to show the rest of the US that it can work – even if it IS for socialist Vermont.
Even if they make it work, someone (ok, me) is sure to say , wrt Vermont, and for example, the Scandinavian countries: "Well, there aren't very many black (or brown) people there, now are there?"
Socialism works better (if not necessarily well) when "my" money is at least going to other whiteys.
(There's started being a lot of discontent in Scandinavia in the last 15 years or so, when they started accepting a lot of refugees with GASP dark skin.)
After seeing that chart, I'm going to figure out how the hell my cats are embezzling me.
By being cats. It's in their nature.
Cats like shiny nickels. Check your change.
Just look under the couch. Everything that is missing will be there. It's the cats storage shed.
Set up a really strong password on your computer. Amazon sells shitloads of cat toys.
Sharight. Like cats don't have keychecks, and such…
And you can't return 'em, either, because they've got spit all over 'em
Oh sure, they're FUN.
But where will you find a set of cat handcuffs?
The National Health Service IS COLLAPSING! I heard this on Fox News!
Fox News also says Parliament is giving Rupert Murdoch a medal!
Obviously no solution can include revenue but other than that I’m sure The Republicans Party will be totally willing to compromise.
Before wealth can trickle down it must first trickle up.
Given that republicans think compromise means ” Democratic capitulation” they are always willing to compromise.
This would be a lot less problematic if so many Democrats didn't also think that.
I really sympathize with the butthurt billionaire. Pitchforks are sharp.
I don't want to know how you know that. I hope all involved were consenting adults.
Nothin' wrong with an occasional ass forking.
We could all win the lottery someday. So shut up.
And just wait until I get my plumber's license.
Lottery = A tax on people who are bad at math.
Besides, we all know the best lottery to win is the ovarian variety.
Meh, the odds on getting rich from the ovarian lottery are worse than the odds of getting rich from the real lottery. Besides, the ovarian lottery has those built-in hazards, what do you call those things? Oh, yeah, kids.
Corporate Profits at All-Time High; Wages at All-Time Low: Can We Call it Class War Yet? http://www.alternet.org/story/156042/Corporate_Pr…
I feel something trickling down, all right.
At least it's the same color as gold.
Zombie Barry Goldwater does not approve this comment.
"He believes that his success is all due to the secret of wealth (do good deeds anonymously)"
Well, so doesn't that mean help others and shut up about it?!
Seems to me someone else not too rich a really, really long time ago had something similar in mind…
to his (sorta) credit, Hughes was actually very reluctant to give Ronson any specifics about his giving. To his detriment, he seemed to genuinely believe that doing so really would destroy his mana and make the magic of anonymous giving go away.
Maurose Frantz… dreams of making enough money to get the hell out of Florida.
Amen, brother.
My cat hated anything with tomato sauce. She'd sniff at it and turn her nose up in disgust as if to say "What? No fish guts?"
So, are you secretly Robin HItchcock?
"Who's been feeding tomatoes to the cat?"
"B. Wayne Hughes,"
How shitty is your first name if you prefer to go by your second name, and that's 'Wayne'.
Bugger might qualify. Or is the name Buggar?
"Bruce"
Great. Now the secret is out.
That guy is bats, man.
Blaine?
Baine.
I claim credit for the assist.
If only you could type worse.
Bradley
Kid Zoom suggests maybe "Butthurt"
Kid Zoom is witty and wise.
He believes that his success is all due to the secret of wealth (do good deeds anonymously) found in a 1939 potboiler, Dr. Hudson’s Secret Journal.
Oh good grief. The Secret had a prequel?
Scott Adams, the creator of Dilbert wrote the same nonsense about fifteen years ago in a book, saying something like if he mediated every day for a thousand days on a particular goal, he'd achieve that goal.
Yea, and dumb luck has nothing to do with it. What if you had hit the jackpot after a hundred times? Would that be your prescription?
Even tho Limbaugh tore him a new one?
Withdrawing that, he seems to be more a libertarian/centrist eccentric.
And then he blogged about how that proved that evolution was false, if I recall. Scott Adams is somewhat of a complete loony toon.
It turns out he's a hypnotist, and that's what he claims he was referring to (altho in the book he mentions nothing about deep hypntoic suggestion).
The evolution thing was a straight-faced snark.
I heartily endorse being born into a family of billionaires. Those lazy poors clearly aren't trying hard enough to be conceived in the right wombs.
I like his, "Never walk down the hall without paperwork in your hands" a little bit, and his, "Women! Am I right, men?" considerably less.
THOZE KITTIEZ GIVEZ I TEH SADZ.
I want to adopt that pitiful skinny one, so he could eat a decent meal. Also the plump one, so he could get some nice fresh air and healthy exercise in my yard full of trees. This is why I had to stop volunteering at the shelter.
The skinny cat is 'shopped. You can tell from the pixels.
A litter box would be suitable to illustrate all those jerbs the Fat Cats are crapping out.
Same kind of cognitive disconnection that keeps incompetents incompetent. Now I understand why rich wingnuts loves the supply side economics because that's their fucking world view. As if demand doesn't matter one fucking bit.
Hey, before I read this article, I was just feeling vaguely on edge about some sort of nebulous danger I couldn't define. Now I'm flat out pissed off and depressed. I fall somewhere between the Midwestern couple and the author of the article, but I feel more like the couple because most of my money goes toward paying for a tiny house worth about 30% less than the mortgage on it, and student loans. And it just feels like it will never, ever end. I've been told that, after ten years in my line of work (software engineer), I'm close to the upper edge of my pay scale. So, what, I'm basically stuck where I am unless I'm in one of those high-paying jobs (*coughcoughfinance*)? Talk about suffocating!
How the hell do we get ahead? I mean, I'd be thrilled to be at the author's level… I've already given up on the idea of hitting the "never need to worry about bills" businesswoman's level.
Well, as somebody on the lowest end of the pay scale of a lower-paying profession, I can only fantasize that I would ever get approved for a mortgage.
Touche. I know all suffering is relative, and that's why I hate bitching about anything whatsoever. Look at it this way: after all the crap I've been through, I doubt I'll ever get approved for a mortgage again. And the way things are now, I'm not sure I'd even advocate for buying a house unless you put, like, 33% down anyway. I got my house early, figuring I was doing the smart thing by buying right out of college and not "throwing away money" renting… well, given the principal drop I've seen, I've probably lost more in equity than I ever would have by renting for a few years. Plus, now I'm stuck with an albatross around my neck, making it impossible for me to take a job anywhere else without walking away or short-selling, further destroying my credit.
So seriously, my advice is to just stay the hell away from mortgages of any kind, unless they're really small.
For starters, we arrange for Nick Hannauer to be appointed to Obama's economic advisory staff…
Nick Hanauer sounds like an awesome guy. It's so refreshing to see a rich person know he's only rich due mostly to luck. It really seems like the three most common ways to get rich in this nation are to luck into it, inherit it, or sociopathically exploit the system (see: financiers).
Here's a clip of him and that idiot Neal Cavutto discussing income inequality.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=madU172f6zI
Tomatoes are in season and I love tomato sammiches so eat a tomato sammich and think happy thoughts.
I am actually not a fan of tomatoes outside of sauces, nor is my wife, but my daughter loves them. Let's see the scientists explain that, huh? Where is the missing tomato link?
"it just feels like it will never, ever end. I'm basically stuck where I am"
You remember that movie "Joe"? A blue collar worker (played by Peter Boyle) becomes unlikely friends with a rich prick? At one point, Joe says he makes $4 an hour and Compton (the rich guy) says he makes $60,000 a year.
The movie was released in 1970. I saw it a few years ago. My first thought was that Joe will never figure out, hasn't yet figured out, that Compton is much more his enemy than the underdogs he hates.
My second thought was, how the hell was Compton making 60K in 1970 (about $30 an hour, by my math, in a year when an ounce of gold was $35)? Where are these jobs that ordinary, "middle-class" people make 60K, 70K, 80K — even now — and don't think it's a fortune? Forgive me for oversharing, but the last full-time job I had was in 2007, and I made 22K. I studied, I got good grades, I showed up and did my work every day at every job I ever had. It's like there was some secret, magic password that I somehow didn't get, and I missed my chance to ever make decent money (and that's before I begin to contemplate the likelihood of my even getting another crappy, badly paid job).
Given that survey after survey has shown that the lower one's income the more charitable one tends to be, it's more likely that doing good deeds is the secret of poverty rather than wealth. I'm beginning to suspect that great wealth brings with it brain-eating prions.
Considering this is all pretty much based on Maimonides, this jackass falls a little short. He comes in at level 2, when Maimonides says the greatest "riches" (spiritual division) is to help your fellow man up by getting him on his feet directly.
Where is this in Maimonides? I've only read Guide to the Perplexed: is it in there somewhere?
According to the link, Mishneh Torah, Laws of Charity, 10:7–14
Thanks!
"Guide to the Perplexed" is an awesome title. That is all.
“If you're in trouble, or hurt or need – go to the poor people. They're the only ones that'll help – the only ones.”
― John Steinbeck, The Grapes of Wrath (Play)
Among other ironies, the rich fucktoad says he identifies with the Joads, because his father was an Oklahoma farmer who made the trip to CA after the dust bowl.
The key is making sure your good deeds help those who will lower your taxes if your help gets them elected to office. And then making sure no one talks about it after the fact.
"I'm beginning to suspect that great wealth brings with it brain-eating prions."
Good.
The only completely true pie chart
Also too: http://www.flickr.com/photos/famewhore/291635623/
"The nice folks in Ohio"
They were from Des Moines, not Ohio.
They're that poor. They can't even afford to live in the state they're from.
Ohio, Iowa, Idaho — they're all the same state, just different pronunciations, like "soda" vs. "pop", right?
I am red-faced with shame for not double-checking, especially as I live in the third state on that list, and am a fan of the t-shirt that says "Idaho State University, Ohio City, Iowa"
The snark in my comment was directed more at myself than anyone else. As a Jersey Girl who thought that the Midwest started at Philadelphia, the Ohio/Iowa/Idaho thing reflected my actual beliefs until I was in my 20s.
Speaking of cats…can i haz pitchfork 2 join angry mob plz?
If I wasn't rich, I would fully support class warfare. As it is, I would prefer a diplomatic solution.
The way you get richer, see, is to encourage the fight then sell weapons.
Has history taught you nothing?
Not to disparage or ignore the whole point of this article, but, Jon Ronson? B Wayne Hughes? Sounds like a Fletch alias and a redneck rapper and I can't think much past that now – but yes yes poor people, that is terrible.
I've been getting a kick out of that Nick Hanauer guy for a while:
http://wonkette.com/472868/ted-people-nix-income-…
His take on income inequality is simple, straightforward, and extremely difficult to argue against. He's not shrill, and he's not approaching the issue like some kind of commie. Income in more hands = more economic activity. Income concentrated in fewer hands = sick, shrinking economy. Duh.
But that doesn't work for the media scream-fests, so it's ignored. If you're not a Koch brother on one side, or an OWS protestor on the other, you don't really exist. Normal people discussing actual issues rationally makes for shitty television.
Oh, he's THAT guy! Wish I'd recognized the name! Yep, cool guy.
Also, it occurred to me, well after I sent the post in, that while Hannauer isn't exactly "angry about the politics of his situation" in terms of how it affects him personally, he has the grace to be angry about how tax policy affects all of us–he thinks that people in his income bracket should be paying at least a 50% rate, a realignment that he and his peers will still profit from by selling more stuff to an expanded middle class.
Pssh, demand-based economics? Are you high?
More super rich people get it than most would think. But there's no story there that will get people riled up. Rich people (like Buffett) who understand and speak up are pretty much ignored because we're all supposed to line up on one extreme or the other. It's more entertaining that way, and nothing ever changes.
Are we all feeling nice and stabby yet? Good.
Best Emperor Palpatine/Fat Tony mashup ever.
Best part of this writeup – Powers Of Ten. Now that was a cool little movie!
Dok — I can't believe you missed an opportunity to show this. Exponentiation of income under communism. When has DokZoom ever not linked a relevant xkcd comic?
Q. When has DokZoom ever not linked a relevant xkcd comic?
A. When he's too busy linking physics-related nuggets of humor instead?
But truly, xkcd is a treasure trove of enjoyment.
Har! Somehow I never saw that'n!!!!
meanwhile our "average guy" Mittens spends the summer vacation with his 30-members family in their multi-millions lakefront private compound, in New Hamster.
Just what America need, another TWO DOZENS spoiled, silver spooned MiniMittens.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/mitt-romne…
Dr. Z were you able to get Vlad the Impaler fixed, did you have to take the Hound back home, or are you using WiFi from somewhere on the road? We missed you at the Seattle meet !!!
Sorry I couldn't make it! I had an adventure!
Vlad the Impala is currently parked at Grumpy's Auto Repair in beautiful Baker City OR, awaiting a diagnostic teardown of its differential. My ex graciously drove from Boise to rescue me after I spent a night at one of that town' fine motels. While there, I watched a great deal of cable TV, including the inexplicable Robert Altman Popeye movie and an HBO documentary about the downfall of Rev. Ted Haggard.
The repair of the differential will be pricey. So, like Rev. Haggard, I spent the weekend burning out my rear end, and will paying the price for a long time.
That Ray was Charles' brother is the real news here.
I have to say, that was my first thought too. :)
Ironically, B Wayne Hughes is the founder of Public Storage, so he makes his dough off the middle class who buy too much crap to fit in their house, and end up paying $250 a month to store old paint, "skinny clothes" and their Beanie Baby collection (aka "retirement fund").
George Carlin would love the irony of this.
Ever notice that your shit is "stuff," and other people's stuff is "shit"?
Ham radio equipment libel!
Also, people pay to store cribs and carseats because they "might have another baby someday"
At which point they will inevitably discover that their cribs no longer meet current safety standards and that the car seats passed their expiration date.
Ask me how I know.
Frigging baby industrial complex.
I cancelled my Public Storage a few years ago, went through all the boxes full of stuff, donated most of it to goodwill, and deducted the donation from my taxes.
Ha ha all OVER you, B. Wayne Hughes!
Then there's the Gini index — a measure of income inequality across an economy. U.S. is around 46 (0 = perfect equality; 100 = Koch Bros. finally have all the money). Thirty years ago we were around 37. Then Reagan took office. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by…
The only thing that surprises me about that is that we're *only* at 46, instead of going from 37 to 80 or something.
"a dickhole billionaire who suffers Wagnerian levels of butthurt because all the lazy people below him have decided that, as a mega-rich guy, he’s suddenly “an enemy of the state” for some reason he cannot fathom."
"and yet if I were to have them killed, I would be the one to go to jail." — Mr. Burns
Needz moare buttsecks.
The way fish are fun if you have a cat.
Hey wait a minute!
Circle of life, man.
Comments on this entry are closed.