



What the Hell Is Michael Kinsley Talking About Watch: Day 1
wonkette: k, tell me something: WHAT THE FUCK IS MICHAEL KINSLEY GOING ON ABOUT HERE
operative: ???
wonkette: it’s like he’s writing from an entirely different world
wonkette: a wondrous world of his imagination
wonkette: “It’s probably true that most billionaires have acquired their wealth in ways that make life better for the rest of us.”
wonkette: WHY IS THAT A GIVEN?
wonkette: WHY IS THAT PRESENTED AS SOMETHING HE ASSUMES HIS AUDIENCE WILL ALREADY TAKE FOR GRANTED?
operative: I enjoy the half-hearted debunking of Social Darwinism
wonkette: i can’t even figure out what he’s arguing because the premises all involve parallel universe logic
operative: way to be a moderate from the late eighteenth century, Mike
wonkette: “Surprisingly, not *all* rich people are morally superior to you.”
operative: “Meanwhile, science undermines the notion that people deserve moral credit for their smarts, daring, vision, dedication and similar virtues, even when these are applied in socially beneficial ways.”
operative: what does that mean?
operative: what the hell is moral credit?
operative: can you use it to buy a plenary indulgence?
operative: was he just building up to the idea that maybe we should have a special billionaire’s tax?
wonkette: HE SAYS HE DOESN’T AGREE WITH THAT IDEA
operative: but, but…
operative: I DON’T UNDERSTAND
Why Be a Billionaire [WP]
READ MORE: billionaires, michael kinsley, operatives, rich people, washington post, wealth
note particularly that in calculating the annual cost of owning three yachts, he states, "Assuming that each one sinks after five years."
JP Morgan's Corsair, built in 1899, was fit for service for the US Navy in World War I. They just don't make yachts like they used to. Or billionaires.
by brooklynite on 03/24/06 04:28 PM
I can't help but wonder whether this column is an elaborate justification for the fact that Kinsley's wife is the head of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, and the Kinsleys are pretty buddy buddy with the Gates family.
Asides from the fact that you admit you didn't understand the column, I really think you didn't understand the column. He's arguing about five ideas all at once.
by Juvenal on 03/24/06 06:15 PM
To leave a comment, please login with your Wonkette comments username and password. (How can I become a commenter?)
Warning: include(floater.inc.php) [function.include]: failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /wk/web/wonkette_assets/wonkette/politics/michael-kinsley/what-the-hell-is-michael-kinsley-talking-about-watch-day-1-162881.php on line 175
Warning: include() [function.include]: Failed opening 'floater.inc.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/share/php:/usr/share/pear:/wk/web/wordpress//inc/') in /wk/web/wonkette_assets/wonkette/politics/michael-kinsley/what-the-hell-is-michael-kinsley-talking-about-watch-day-1-162881.php on line 175



